Amid a push from the Canadian government to allow more Chinese electric vehicles into Canada, Transport Minister Steve MacKinnon says the government will review where those cars will be allowed to drive, which comes amid growing concerns about national security risks.
When asked by Global News if the Canadian government would limit Chinese EV’s access to Canadian military and government facilities, Transport Minister Steve MacKinnon said “that will be part of a more cross-governmental review of that matter that would involve Public Safety and other departments.”
When pressed as to why the Canadian government would allow cars into Canada that could potentially require restrictions on where they could go, MacKinnon said the government is “always on the lookout for risks” that connected vehicles bring.
Concerns over Chinese cars ability to collect sensitive information have been routinely highlighted by Ontario Premier Doug Ford, who often refers to them as “spy cars.”
…
Germany recently announced a ban on some Chinese vehicles in secure military and government locations, according to German publication Der Spiegel, over concerns that the cars built-in sensors and cameras could record sensitive data and forward it to Chinese security authorities.
…
The U.K., Poland and Czechia also have full or partial bans on Chinese vehicles on military bases, with Poland telling military members not to connect their work phones to the systems of those cars.
The United States has banned Chinese auto giant BYD from having their cars at one of their biggest overseas military bases in Okinawa, Japan.
…
Or you could prohibit all cars from communicating with their manufacturers or recording data that isn’t internal and necessary for diagnostics.
I sort of agree, but at the same time they could easily sneak it back in (a ban does nothing) and of you allow ANY data recording then you also have the possibility of collecting and hiding the kind of data you’re looking to ban anyways.
I think a better option would be two parts.
-
force automakers that install communication gear to make it in such a way that it can be disabled. Like easily have the consumer or a mechanic disconnect a communications box and have that not brick the car.
-
Require open source software and allow me to update the software on my own vehicle. If I don’t trust the software then I’ll build from source and re-flash it myself. The open source community would probably also help build features and stuff that automakers could use later on. Everyone wins. Except for the people at automakers that want to steal your data.
Your solutions don’t negate your raised complaint.
- Telematics units have to be seperate and user unplugable.
This makes it so you can disable telematics. They could sneakily put it somewhere else but that starts to get iffy and if you get caught doing it then you cause huge problems.
- open source software
Anything that’s done to it now is done in the open. Service tools would be out in the open at that point as well so you would never be required to go to the dealer for service if you don’t trust them.
Hidden Telematics units would be detectable and the open source community might even go to work creating new software that’s private.
-
No no no! Why would we want to improve the lives of everyone? We WANT spyware. Just not Chinese spyware.
Should ban Tesla from those same areas.
It’s all relatively modern vehicles at this point. They all have varying means of collecting and transmitting data. It seems pretty easy to just limit all private vehicles to designated parking lots and utilize vehicles managed by the specific sites for any local traffic needs.
China China Bo Bina Banana Fana Fo Fina…yet another article about…China!
The Shaaaaame Gaaame!
Cope harder @Scotty@scribe.disroot.org
Chinese EVs everywhere.
Chinese EVs everywhere.
Canada’s import quota for Chinese EVs has a cap of 49,000 vehicles, some 3% of the total car market in Canada.
One third of these ‘made in China’ cars already arrived in Canada, another third of the quota has already been cleared. Among these two thirds, 90% come from Elon Musk’s Tesla factory in Shanghai, China.
The few Chinese EV brands offered in Canada so far are SUVs with price tags between CAD 120,000 to CAD 160,000.
Edit: The price tag for the Tesla’s in Canada is around CAD 40,000.
It seems you really do not understand how business works.
If you have a small market in number of buyers it is only worth while to service wealthy customers to get the margins needed to both service the customers and make business sense. See the recent business YouTube content of servicesing wealthy vs mass market customers for small markets. I can give you a few.
Instead of comparing just the price Tesla cars vs Chinese brands made in China.
Compare the number, price, and distribution of price by number between Tesla’s (made anywhere) vs Chinese cars (made in China)
The artificial limit tells you something. Chinese cars made to good.
If Chinese cars are soon expensive, then what’s the price of Chinese vs US vs EU cars in ASEAN countries or in Latin America?
Who’s winning?
Cope harder.
What I often find strange here is this claim by many users to always know better anyway, even though the comments make no sense, paired with an absurdly weird second-hand intimidation. And all this just to portray Canada as the villain and China as the ultimate solution for everything.




