• 35 Posts
  • 144 Comments
Joined 2 months ago
cake
Cake day: May 9th, 2026

help-circle
  • I fully agree and I honestly don’t know why people don’t vote. It seems hard to get people to give a shit.

    I also think there are layers to it. For instance in more urban areas, there’s definite voter apathy and less vote per population. I met a person who has lived their entire life in Toronto and the only election they’ve ever voted in was the recent federal election because they didn’t want PP. And that person worked in provincial government! Like, you can’t be closer to the direct effects of whoever the premier is.

    But an interesting viewpoint I read recently about rural areas and voting decisions is that they vote based on what party the majority will be to ensure that their rural area can get the support/funding it needs (i.e. some form of bias in the general function of government).

    For instance if they voted for an NDP in the rural area, what’s the likelihood that the majority Conservative government would approve funding and legislation that they put forward? Or advocate for jobs and be heard because it becomes a party topic rather than an opposition topic who the majority have no interest in making them look good.













  • Worth knowing that most of the immigration preceded the Holocaust, and Palestinians treated them as illegal immigrants (which they were), not as invaders.

    Look, that same refugee trope founding myth is what north America used with the pilgrims, so it’s beneficial to deconstruct that. Because it is the same founding myth of Israel.

    It’s also worth reading early writings from Zionists about the “type” of Jewish people the Zionists wanted for the new state. They basically believed that the refugees were too poor and of the wrong mentality - essentially tainting what they were trying to build. Literally a screening office was setup to allow or disallow certain types of Jews. Zionists only acquiesced because they needed more people to bolster their numbers and reasons for expansion

    https://palestinenexus.com/articles/eugenicism

    From the late 19th century through the 1950s, Zionist leaders adopted a selective immigration policy designed to exclude ‘undesirable’ Jews. The goal of the Zionist movement was to build a Jewish state in a Palestinian Arab land, and that required Jewish capitalists, skilled laborers, professionals and fighters, not children, elderly people or refugees. The Zionist leadership rejected persecuted, disabled, destitute, sick, diseased and elderly Jews because they were persecuted, disabled, destitute, sick, diseased and elderly. They instead prioritized what they called “halutzim,” or young, healthy Zionist ideologues willing to sacrifice their youth, capital, labor and life for the cause. This is the eugenist history of Zionism, in brief.







  • I disagree with your framing because it makes it seem like Zionism isn’t inherently hateful, just some people coopting the ideology are.

    But the very founders and people that created the ideology were hateful, as a matter of fact.

    You’re framing an ethno-supremacist ideology that was created at the same time that other very hateful ethno-supremacist ideologies were created and trying to say it isn’t inherently hateful.

    That’s like saying Naziism wasn’t inherently hateful, but people coopted the ideology. They’re literally of the same cloth, friend.




  • Maybe I’m just not intrenched enough to hear the consensus pushback that I’m sure exists on the tabernacle level; and I do refrain from demanding an answer from Jewish people cuz I think that’s wrong. But its a 50/50 for who is willing to denounce zionism and who seems to have bought into the propaganda.

    I think, unfortunately, that in Canada the ratio is more 70/30 with majority supporting Zionism, while the US is closer to 50/50.

    Historically and preceding WW2, Jewish immigrants preferred going to the US - Canada had a nasty habit of turning Jews away (even during and after the holocaust). The existinf US Jewish population managed to grow and create a culture that was very separate from what Zionism started to build in the late 19th/early 20th century in Europe.

    Because Canada’s Jewish population grew up with Zionist ideology being relevant to a great degree, the ratio is more skewed.

    Like the other user said, anti-zionist Jewish voices in Canada are lacking in institutions and numbers especially in comparison to the US. They exist and need to be supported as well.