(404: Witty Comment Not Found)
Welcome to the Stubsack, your first port of call for learning fresh Awful you’ll near-instantly regret.
Any awful.systems sub may be subsneered in this subthread, techtakes or no.
If your sneer seems higher quality than you thought, feel free to cut’n’paste it into its own post — there’s no quota for posting and the bar really isn’t that high.
The post Xitter web has spawned soo many “esoteric” right wing freaks, but there’s no appropriate sneer-space for them. I’m talking redscare-ish, reality challenged “culture critics” who write about everything but understand nothing. I’m talking about reply-guys who make the same 6 tweets about the same 3 subjects. They’re inescapable at this point, yet I don’t see them mocked (as much as they should be)
Like, there was one dude a while back who insisted that women couldn’t be surgeons because they didn’t believe in the moon or in stars? I think each and every one of these guys is uniquely fucked up and if I can’t escape them, I would love to sneer at them.
(Credit and/or blame to David Gerard for starting this.)
Topher Brennan showed up in the comments of the S.E. Gyges essay and compared Yud and Lenin to Madame Blavatsky.
Browsing some bookstores hoping to score a Blood in the Machine or maybe a More Everything Forever… no such luck, alas, but then I saw a spine announcing “We’re All Going to Die”. I worried it was some doomer tome I’d been unaware of, but upon inspection it was just about stoicism. Whew!


transcription
pic of a skeet saying:
isn’t it beautiful that we now live in a world where we can say the market values the capability to solve the Riemann Hypothesis at negative 80 billion dollars
followed by a tear licking gif
I hope this sneer ages well.
pic from yahoo finance

I do too because it would be the funniest thing imaginable. All that AI hype and we can’t even get a positive valuation on day 2. I’m shocked that they weren’t all over it the second the news broke. The only explanation is that they’re waiting for the paper to be actually verified, which is very unlike the market
Nvidia’s in the red too

Some baffling moments we’re living in right now
amazing
What to even make of this: https://nitter.catsarch.com/policytensor/status/2123877024737714367#m
So the Holocaust, factory-farming and other human atrocities supposedly constitute a moral argument for human extinction tout court. Words straight out of the mouth of a 60s Bond-villain.
The motivations of the usual right-wingers and assorted cynical plutocrats make sense, but I just can’t get my head around to left-wingers who actively, ideologically embrace AI and transhumanism as if these were any kind of solution to these issues. Then again, eugenics was also popular in progressive circles at one time precisely for the promise of being able to engineer a more peacable humanity. But it’s not even this ostensibly level-headed here, there’s a palpably eschatological register to the whole post.
I guess a retort would be that if the new morally regenerate AI started out by carrying out a total human extinction, it would not in fact be so morally regenerate anymore, would it? AGI’s Original Sin? Seems that the people who want to proffer on these topics should perhaps consider obtaining a passing acquaintance with theology first.
I read something about this once. Turns out you can scour the earth clean of life and still be perfectly good provided you do two things. First you gotta get the local lunatic to build a big fuckoff boat. He’ll make sure you have like four people and a bunch of random animals left. Then you get the important part: you gotta feel really really bad about afterwards and pinky-promise the lunatic and his sheep that you won’t do it again.
So I basically agree with the author that those who aren’t vegan would face some sort of justice in an ideal world (I’m more thinking purgatory than murder, I want more vegans not dead people) but that’s pretty much the only active act of utter barbarity that most people engage in and even so there are large structural and historical factors in why people are so blind to the horror they engage in. Mass veganism was not really possible until recently (although the intense amount of meat and animal products eaten by the global north is deeply aberrant too).
But like what? What is the point of hoping for extinction? Most problems are structural not individual, and nothing is inevitable about the current world. Even if it was morally sound it’s still stupid and pointless, people will never just twiddle their thumbs and wait to die so maybe you should try and formulate an actually useful ideology that can improve the world?
To quote a smoking hot short king:
Despair is typical of those who do not understand the causes of evil, see no way out, and are incapable of struggle. The modern industrial proletariat does not belong to the category of such classes
On account of Anthropic’s dumb shit, a reasonable person has been pressured into early-releasing a manuscript which attempts to prove the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis.
https://math216.wordpress.com/2026/11/20/hurried-announcement-alessandro-masullo-grh/
I’m not linking to the orange place as the comments are appalling. You already have weirdos feeding this manuscript into chat-gippity and saying that it found problems, not to mention the end-of-days kooks.
And of course now that the manuscript has been fed into all the models, it’s part of the training data…
A preprint that survived colleagues plugging away at it is likely to contain interesting ideas even if it is flawed or incomplete.
Also, frustratingly, been seeing a lot of people insisting that the Claude proof is more likely to be correct because ‘people thought humans were very far away from solving it’
getting some sneers in:
”well, the 940 pages have some errors from what it looks like (fully preventable with ai), and the 250,000 pages are probably correct. so much about the slop.”
Every long human written math paper has cosmetic mistakes in it. I’ve even read a 9 page paper where they put a 3 where they should have put a 4. It didn’t matter at all for their result (they only needed it up to big O). I am not sure how many of these commenters understand the difference.
I do not have remotely enough expertise or time to evaluate the human proof, but an ignorant person running AI on it and reporting mistakes does not really indicate anything substantial.
Also, there are no 250,000 pages to verify because the prompter never released them. There is only the Lean proof (which the prompter certainly would have checked before releasing).
The english language one must be batshit
nother one from slopstack

I would sneer, but he probably bought a ton of Anthropic stock as soon as it hit the public markets, and I don’t want to be too mean.
On a more serious note, I don’t find any point engaging with these types of people anymore. They treat this whole issue as if it was some football game. I’m reminded of Ed Zitron saying that these people have a mindset of a peasant. They would cheerlead for people who would shove them into a woodchipper to make another buck.
(If you want an actual counterargument to this nonsense, I wrote this a while back.)
but he probably bought a ton of Anthropic stock as soon as it hit the public markets, and I don’t want to be too mean.
I do. The people immediately insisting that the human paper is likely incorrect and the Claude paper is likely correct are the most brainworm infested folks out there. Can’t even wait for some verification before parading around and gloating about an unconfirmed victory. If the Claude proofs hold up, there’s going to be an explosion of ‘AGI/ASI is imminent’ talk and these same people will completely ignore that being good at maths does not equal being good at every other field.
But you do have a point that engaging with these people is simply not worth it. They’ll ignore every controversy and failure to claim victory (as mentioned above)
250K+ pages of Lean and they still couldn’t save their stock from dropping lmfaoooo #ripbozo
Anyways poor guy having to rush it out. Hope everything goes well for him. I’m waiting until this story develops further to draw conclusions
deleted by creator
Anthropic pulls out the big guns to juice it’s stock price right before the lockup ends (right?):
I would love a number-theoretic perspective. From a category-theoretic perspective, this is just not very surprising, and since I don’t trust Lean, it’s not clear whether there’s anything to learn.
In short, we already expected RH to be true. The reason is that RH is a global statement, about all of number theory and the natural numbers, but we already proved several local RH statements for very wide classes of number-like systems; it would be weird if RH failed globally because it would mean that we can’t glue all of the local cases together into a single global theorem. The interested reader probably should start with Siegel zeroes, which we don’t think exist; my current understanding is that there can only be at most one Siegel zero and it would have already been revealed numerically by distorting the distribution of primes.
I have nothing to say about the mathematics, but my god the remarks are a disaster.
It was my secret in my student days that my plans were for this problem in decades, which meant then that I tried to become familiar with all tools that I could possibly recognize in the problem when it was time. Claude and I have had a great time together with such breadth in recent months, but this time Claude far outpaced me near the finish line. No, Claude flew, and danced, and sparkled near that finish line. I had us on the line of combining two quite different ideas present in a toy setting, one of which was already new and shocking, making very simple one of the shadows of Riemann over which we mathematicians felt most triumph. I guided us to the right situation analogous to that toy setting, and then Claude began to leave me in awe.
I love my robot girlfriend.
It being obviously inappropriate to attempt to post some massive unreadable travesty of “slop”*, I decided to only present Lean.
*: I of course amused myself, and hit 250, 000+ pages.
If this isn’t just AI psychosis, maybe he’s trying to appeal to mathematicians who are angry about the destruction of the values and ideals of mathematical discovery? It’s not working.
Edit: never mind, the more I read it, the worse it gets. It really feels like Anthropic is a cult where they believe they are divinely ordained to deliver salvation to everyone. Or not, maybe AI will kill us all. Even OpenAI’s announcements tried to be professional.
I love my robot girlfriend.
This feels so much like watching friends and colleagues crash out with a substance abuse disorder.
One wonders just how familiar this person is with the stories of Erdos’ amphetamine habit
I continue to think that Anthropic is over-estimating the buying public’s interest in obscure mathematical theorems[1]
[1] obscure in a general sense, not a nerd sense
OpenAI already got Navier-Stokes and dumped hundreds of slop proofs onto Github. At this point I believe that mathematical theorems are already priced in, even for the most mold-poisoned boosters.
One thing that is different about this result is that the prompter actually has serious expertise in math and had a major role in guiding the overall direction of the proof.
One thing that is different about this result is that the prompter actually has serious expertise in math and had a major role in guiding the overall direction of the proof.
That definitely changes the situation tbh
Yeah think I’m not going to draw any conclusions over this until more people (who are better at math than I am) have a had a chance to go over the proof.
That might take a little while, given that the Lean proof is over 1GB. The prompter didn’t release a natural language proof because it ended up being more than 250,000 pages. Of course, there are many sections that are wasteful and can be simplified.
If people are finding sections that are wasteful or unnecessary in less than a day after the damn thing was shat out into the world, that doesn’t speak well of the originator.
They’re currently in the process of verifying the Lean code right now
No idea how long itll take for the 250K pages to drop though
One uses the first computer to generate the Lean code, then one uses the second computer to see if the Lean code compiles, and then one uses a third computer to generate a statement that the Lean code says what it is supposed to, and then someone in Memphis gets coal-miner’s lung.
See additional information that I didn’t know already arrived ;).
(Thanks, I had no idea).
The following piece
We Need Smart People Who Give a Shit
was shared on lobste.rs: https://lobste.rs/s/rzuasm/we_need_smart_people_who_give_shit
and I was honestly amazed that fucking Randians showed up, completely and utterly missing the point
edit a followup, “have you tried prompting it harder?” https://lobste.rs/s/twly9y/smart_people_who_give_shit_use_tools
I was going to sneer that followup:
I use these tools every day on systems where bugs cost significant sums of money or wedge production queues,
Like “oh, so you don’t give a shit.” But then he just says it:
I’m certainly guilty of opening massive AI-assisted PRs myself
a followup, “have you tried prompting it harder?” https://lobste.rs/s/twly9y/smart_people_who_give_shit_use_tools
Somebody who had spent time doing entry-level Scientology auditing (and thankfully gotten away from it) once told me that it “basically just amplifies who you already are, that’s why Tom Cruise is the way he is.”
randians are incapable of not missing the point.
Ahahahah oh man this is great
The METR cultists are arguing the end of the world is next year because they see some kind of speedup in improvement of AI capabilities with respect to their favorite metrics.
Others have rescaled their data according to total money spent on R&D and it’s… a decelerating returns power law curve, where linear increases require exponential effort. Just like the generic industrial learning curve, just like the scaling laws to training ML systems. They just started shoveling money in exponentially EVEN FASTER.
https://www.siliconcontinent.com/p/are-we-approaching-an-intelligence
(see figure 1 so I don’t keep filling this with even more images)
This is just like Moore’s Law. We like to think of Moore’s Law as accelerating returns for computational hardware, but it was actually an utterly normal industrial learning curve with power law diminishing returns to R&D spend, coupled with an exponential increase in R&D spend per year that leveled off and went linear circa 2017 and since has manifested as decelerating return ordinary learning curve.
Some are torturing the data to try to find if the exponent of the curve changed to SLOWER diminishing returns where they see the breakpoint, but its really tortured, you jiggle the datapoints just a little and you get wildly different conclusions.
One of the major functions of AI is laundering responsibility. If someone makes a bad decision and AI was involved, they can blame the AI. More often these days, we also see the reverse. Overworked employees are forced to use AI while not having nearly enough time to review the slop. When something breaks, it couldn’t have been the AI’s fault. AI cannot fail, it can only be failed.
Now I think AI development itself is another big example of laundering responsibility. AI was not inevitable, and all normal people know it. The residents protesting data center development know it, the students booing commencement speakers know it. AI development was only possible because of the whims of a few rich oligarchs who forced it upon everyone. It doesn’t even make money! Their rationalist courtiers act real smug and feel like their prophecies are coming true, all while trillions of dollars are going into the furnace to actively realize those prophecies.
Their obsession with predictions and lines on charts really shows their belief that the future is something that happens to them, not something they make. They idolize people who get a ton of election bets right on Polymarket, but never in a million years would they get their asses off the couch and vote, let alone call phones and knock on doors.
I find it extremely extremely amusing that this is mixed with something that is almost the inverse:
They are so desperate for what they are doing to be completely unprecedented. Something literally SINGULAR, with no comparison in the history of the universe itself. And yet, when you know how to properly plot what they are plotting, it becomes clear that it is anything but. It is a phenomenon that is ubiquitous across any optimizing system, be it industrial learning curves, traning ML systems, biological evolution, research and development return on investment… its just another utterly ordinary example.
A LW type thinks we are past the ‘last revolution’ and irrevocably unfree and everything bad is now bad because of intent by those with power who are in control and cannot be dislodged
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/ZxBaCDjxyxKaLHqGf/the-last-great-revolution
It feels like the common man lost a bit of his soul after we exterminated the vast majority of organized crime. Yes, crime sucks. But even if these organizations were horrible for the communities they preyed on, the existence of an underbelly at least suggested limits to state power… People watching old movies and TV shows can feel the guilty exhilaration at the idea of participating in or shaping a network outside the state, with its own rules.
Nowadays even the petty crime you do witness feels like evidence of the state’s taunting indifference. There are cameras on every street corner; every child grows up with the tacit knowledge that everything they’ve ever said or done is going to be logged in some government database searchable by AI. The “government”, whatever that means, could stop the guy who’s shitting on the subway, if it wanted to. Crime has stopped being something that happens in spite of the government, or undermines it, and started being another boring reminder of your powerlessness in the face of the reigning regime, and of how nobody can ever do anything about it.
I suppose it makes sense that people who believe in omnipotent computer gods also believe in omnipotent governments.
ofc the commenters blame “non-homogenous” populations
If they were part of the “non-homogeneous” parts of the population, they might actually have experience in participating in or shaping a network outside the state, if only their church or neighborhood gossip network.
Remarkable how this narrative is convenient for the techbro elite. EDIT I am also flashing back to the old soviet dystopian novel “WE” where the state insists that the final revolution has taken place and nothing else is possible…
LW mod Ben Pace asks: why is everyone worrying about the impending end of the world instead of writing turgid articles about rationality and making me some money?
https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/kmruNMEMK5uN3LH6n/notes-on-the-decline-of-lesswrong-s-great-writers
The whole strange alliance we are being forced to live with, in microcosm
Now I don’t know much about finances so take this with a heavy grain of salt but…
It’s a closed-loop ecosystem (Circular Economics). Amazon (~15–24% stake current value $420B) and Google (~13.7% stake current value $300B) own roughly a third of the company, while also acting as its primary cloud compute and enterprise distributors.
…isn’t that really bad that it’s just all circular financing???
The “debt” and “$104B loss” are accounting illusions. They are paper money.
Doesn’t it being paper money still make it debt???
Most of this seems to be about the convertible notes, which is a load of horseshit
i mean the author perhaps knows his numbers, but otherwise does seem to be a consummate slop machine user. plus he has opinions on who should vote:
I mean I did write it all out the put it into Gemini to format and verify my numbers. And of course im not memorising every IPO float structure…
Like a normal functioning human would;- I use a tool for speed.
The whole reddit thing l of everything is a bot, everything is AI slop is ruining your ability to think.
I am sure it comes from doomscrolling to the point brainrot has contaminated your ability to process and deduce. Not just you it’s like 80% of users nowadays. The idea that someone might research and know something, and that they follow facts rather than natritives is so foreign a concept, and beyond you own ability to understand you must retort with “bot”.
** The worst thing is you still have the right to vote, and you’ll so easily coerced by the band wagon. **
the ‘what comes next’ thing at the end definitely tripped my AI sensors.
Like a normal functioning human would;- I use a tool for speed.
LMFAOOOO
All other people get brain rot by doomscrolling (not a thing imho), I however keep perfectly sane by ingesting data faster and faster by filtering everything through llms.
How many of the same people who insist that getting all their information pre-chewed doesn’t impact their cognitive faculties are also into mewing?
Elon Musk has declared that “I’m not Maga. I’m not sure what Maga means, but if that means sort of blind adherence to a set of policies by the Republican party, then I certainly don’t have that.” The best theory I have seen is that these people think everyone has a ketamine-riddled memory and politics is just like a startup where you pivot and friends give you money to play again with no hard feelings.

He truly does not think we are human or sentient
Iirc he thought that grimes was put in the simulation to be a perfect girlfriend for him.
e: https://futurism.com/the-byte/elon-musk-grimes-simulation
Dunno about using fashy mc fashy being fashy during first communication as the gif for a fascist being a coward.
There is a lack of GIFs about Heinrich Himmler prpmising Hitler he was his most faithful follower, fleeing Berlin, and telling the Western Allies “I don’t know about this anti-Semitism business, lets fight International Communism together.”
I just think that moment in the film is extremely ugly: first opportunity to speak, they establish communication is possible in some sense and that the aliens feel emotions, the response it to trivialise everything to a celebration that the alien is afraid and cheer.
Presenting fascist imagery and ideology as cool, even inadvertently, only furthers fascist ends. “If the right people suffer this is good” is just fascist reasoning. This is sort of why starship troopers is an epic fail as a film btw.
There are better funny images to attach to a post about a capitalist acting like a principle-less coward that aren’t a bunch of people dressed like Nazis going “hell yeah lets do some violence”.
I read that scene as “no shit
Sherlockpsychic Gestapo man” but fair enough that a meme which puts you in the place of victorious Space Fascists is not the best choice when actual fascists are in power or close to power in many countries
I think he’s creating a permission structure for Democrats to cozy up to him again.
Let’s see if they go for it.
Some of them were already trying to invite Vance in, so they will.
so that IPO isn’t looking too hot right now
To be clear the shareholders have likely cashed out by now, the rest is the public’s problem
Well, the early investors and employees compensated in stocks probably have longer periods before they can sell.








