• givesomefucks@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    12
    arrow-down
    34
    ·
    edit-2
    2 months ago

    The vast majority of that should have been forgiven years or decades ago under existing programs…

    It’s just they put loan servicers in charge of the loan forgiveness programs, so they were intentionally understaffed and prone to errors.

    When people hold up dollar amounts like Biden is doing a lot, that number is inflated by fraudulent interest Biden is just paying with our tax money.

    Is it better than him ignoring the problem like Obama and trump? Sure.

    But he’s literally doing the bare minimum of enforcing programs that have existed for decades, and drastically overpaying meaning for the same dollar amount, more people should be getting loan forgiveness.

    It sounds great if you only read headlines tho…

    The Republican Supreme Court keeps blocking him.

    And if Hillary’s primary campaign hadn’t taken over the DNC, we’d be coming out of Bernie’s second term with the most progressive SC in history.

    Making excuses for Biden always just ends up arguing against moderate politicians like Biden. It’s their fault we’re in this shitty situation to begin with

    • mozz@mbin.grits.dev
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      40
      arrow-down
      3
      ·
      edit-2
      2 months ago

      Hey, neat! It’s a couple of talking points.

      When people hold up dollar amounts like Biden is doing a lot, that number is inflated by fraudulent interest

      “They are lying to you about numbers, don’t pay attention to the numbers! Just in general; no numbers. Pay attention to my vague, inflated, ever-shifting claims, instead.”

      Biden is just paying with our tax money.

      “This politician is spending our money!” (mostly this one is emotional impact – it is true that practically everything the government does is spending people’s tax dollars, but suggesting that some specific thing is them spending your money is alarming to people on a survival level and triggers this kind of hatred for the situation overall)

      But he’s literally doing the bare minimum

      “Okay, he is making progress, but it doesn’t count!”

      drastically overpaying meaning for the same dollar amount, more people should be getting loan forgiveness.

      Literally no idea what you are talking about here. I think you messed up by making it too specific, so it’s factually untrue – you gotta keep it within the realm of technically true but wildly misleading things (“paying with our tax money”).

      Are you suggesting that when Biden forgives $10k of student loan debt, the borrower is receiving less than $10k worth of forgiveness? How would that even work? I think you got too excited at the keyboard and let your typing-froth get too close to factual reality and kind of exposed the fact that it’s all made up bad faith bullshit.

      It sounds great if you only read headlines tho…

      “I’m the well informed one! If you disagree with me you are foolish / naive / victim of propaganda / etc!”

      Making excuses for Biden always just ends up arguing against moderate politicians like Biden. It’s their fault we’re in this shitty situation to begin with

      Bringing factual reality = “making excuses for Biden”

      General bad faith bitterness and blaming. It’s actually pretty remarkable how effective this is at turning “Biden tried to forgive $500B in student loans and has been fighting against efforts to stop him and still has succeeded in forgiving $167B and is still trying to do more” into “it’s his fault student loans even exist in the first place! Fuck him for pretending to care with his massive student loan forgiveness program positively impacting millions of people!”

      Overall I rate this like a 4/10. You hit a bunch of general points that can produce an emotional impact and could literally be applied to anything, and you hit honestly a pretty good rhythm of nonstop firehosing claims wrapped up in a way that they could produce an impact. You got too factual, though; even one claim that is objective and testable and 100% false (the thing about “drastically overpaying” which doesn’t even make sense as applied to student loan forgiveness), can sort of snap people back into the realization that you’re just jabbering anything you can come up with to attack Biden with no connection to reality.

    • TachyonTele@lemm.ee
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      6
      arrow-down
      2
      ·
      2 months ago

      So you don’t want any student loans debt forgiveness at all, is what you’re saying.

      • givesomefucks@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        5
        ·
        2 months ago

        Why?

        I stand by what I said even tho it’s unpopular:

        It’s better than nothing, but nothing to brag about.

        And we’re giving the companies that fraudulently refused to process forgiveness the extra illegal interest they’ve been charging.

        It only sounds like Biden is accomplishing great things if you don’t know the details and just listen to headlines…

        Which is what we give trump supporters shit for.