I know, the post tile is rather bait like, however I wanted to stir discussion amongst you.
As you know I’m a mod of the Linux for Leftists community so it might be quite counter-intuitive that someone knowledgeable on computers and Linux would have an anti-technological position. The thing is, I do not have such a position, that would be anti-Marxist and most importantly: idiotic.
The problems I have with technology stem from capitalism, however that doesn’t change the fact I enjoy using more “outdated” technological solutions to my problems in life and “kkkrapital$m sukkks” is not the discussion I’d like to foster today. I believe as individuals and society we are over reliant on unnecessarily advanced technology and should seek alternatives to distance ourselves from this.
Let me ask you: “How reliant in your day to day life are you on your smartphone?”
The question is more in the likes of, how many of your previous devices or items have been replaced by it? For example a watch, a timer, an alarm, a calculator, a payment method, a music player, a news reader, a video device and more.
It’s an everything machine, and when it fails you that’s when you essentially lose access to everything. Even if I buy a ticket online, you bet I’m printing it out just for that added feeling of security. I’ve always been the type of person that likes my devices to be very redundant, so that when one fails me I can either easily replace or repair it. I also like for my devices to be reliant and durable as well as well made for the purpose they are meant to serve.
I have what I would like to call a functionally minimalist mindset. That’s why I have problems with computers and smartphones as they are not only everything machines for most, they are slowly getting worse for the mainstream and a revolution isn’t coming soon.
So what do I do? Lifestylism lmao
Something that helps me not only enforce a reliability in my life, but also ground it in the real world as with every future year we are more and more pushed into the digital. Unfortunately capitalism has made the digital not a liberating power, but a force of alienation and control. Thus I try to distance myself very much from social media, and I’ve been doing it quite well. Since 2013 or 2014 as quite a young idiot I made a smart decision. “Social media sucks”, and I’ve never managed to get into Facebook, Instagram, Snapchat and the like.
Only recently have I’ve gotten into any kind of social media, like Reddit or now Lemmygrad. But that is because of you my lovely comrades. You made the places worth registering to. Thank you.
But returning, I also have a certain love for the material. Something I can touch, inspect, smell and admire for it’s craftsmanship. I own several purely mechanical machines that have been well replaced by the digital. I also have old digital machines that are also what I like to call fictionally minimalist. Like a Casio F-91W watch or a TI-82 graphic calculator. (Solid things, they don’t make now 'em like they used to.) An addiator, a mechanical wind-up watch (I still prefer my Casio F-91W) and get this. Six typewriters. I have somewhat of addiction to them.
I have to say, all of these have made my life not just more cluttered. But more “real”. I can’t describe it, but interacting with them feels more authentic than interacting with a smartphone or even a laptop. There is just something about them that allows me not just distraction free work, but a focused mindset on task I’ve set in front of me. They make my life weirdly enough, easier.
I’ve found myself gravitating more and more to these low tech solutions, not just because of interest of curiosity. But real genuine desire to actually use them on a day to day basis.
Do you find yourself having similar experiences when it comes to technology? That it has been more of a hindrance than a help to whatever you are trying to do?
(Excuse me if the post lacks structure or sense. I’ve yet to get good at proper writing, and not just streams of thoughts.)
EDIT: It seems this post garnered a few downvotes. Please, leave a comment! Let the struggle session begin!
Yeah, especially in cars, like you see the features and half of them will literally never be used ever
Yes! When I posted this I thought of editing the post to include information about cars nad how they’ve been turned into absolutely unfixable and unreliable machines due to overabundance of electronics in their functionality. If I am going to have a car, it better be a Trabant lmao
I’m still driving a 1999 and newer cars I can’t even understand how to drive them as they have so many complicated features. I also find it funny people want all these extra features like this but are fine with not getting a manual and drive automatics even though they seem to want to much control for everything else
People living with disabilities use their phone to help them find and access services which they need. Paying bills, getting cash at the bank, etc all previously required physically queuing up.
Yes - not all modernization and tech “advancement” has improved people’s lives. Postmodernism is a side effect of a capitalist system. Communication has become a commodity to be consumed.
Unfortunately we haven’t yet created a Linux-like philosophy that applies to mobile phones. With Unix, you use files or file handles to interface between command line tools. You incorporate the tools together in scripts to create more complex applications. How that philosophy can be transformed into a mobile device? I’m not sure.
Tech needs creative people to build things that help others live better rather than screw their life up.
And the ability to find services that make things simpler isn’t just something that has affected disabled people but across the board it has been made easier
Fr without the work of GNU and FOSS advocates we would be in a deeper shithole.
Definitely, with Linux on my computer I can’t even fathom the idea of returning to Windows in the slightest capacity.
I’m at a point where any computer (including smart devices) that doesn’t run a GNU/Linux or BSD derivative where I, the user, have full control over is completely useless to me. Proprietary OSs are so limiting, they’re like a plastic toy hammer for kids in comparison to GNU/Linux, which is like a real metal hammer.
Not just a metal hammer, a whole goddamn workshop.
I am actually optimist about the future of tech thanks to FOSS, there are people all around the world collaborating to develop open solutions for every sector. It really is the biggest collaboration project in humanity hitherto.
Yup, the existence of FOSS is always my favorite optimism boost and favorite argument against the profit motive being the main driving force behind innovation and improvement. Truly the best thing to grace this earth were all of these contributors that made our software and computing experiences better.
I use Windows for games sometimes and this is what has made it less unbearable for me:
- using Windows 10 LTSC instead of the regular version
- using scoop as the package manager
- WSL for basic things like SSH
It is such a garbage OS. I cannot believe how shit it is.
I’m still using MacOS as my main OS since my laptop I got in 2013 still works but have been looking at trying to switch to Linux more and more as of lately and trying to stop using any close-sourced software
I recently did the work of installing Linux on my T2 Mac, but aside from specific software that only runs on Linux, I’m not sure when to actually use it.
Same, I use an iPod for music, I try to pay with cash when possible and my main laptop is 15 years old. It’s idiotic that they want to move already existing offline things into cloud based subscription based ones, and how they slow down and stop updates for capable devices, and how they intentionally make things extremely hard to repair.
On the smart phone, it is an incredible tool humans have dreamed of for years (The collective information of humanity and the ability to communicate with people 1000s of kilometers away all in your pocket), yet the capitalists managed to make it as addictive as possible, to the point people would do horribly stupid things to please its algorithm and spend 7+ hours a day on it mindlessly scrolling without purpose.
Maybe it’s a power humans weren’t meant to have or its a ploy by the capitalists to distract and deceive the working class, but I digress.
Tragic, when you put it like that. There potential for smartphones isn’t close to being reached and it’s got very little to do with how much more advanced the tech gets. I’ve been asking around if people have old laptops, etc. I’m thinking of purpose building something that’s as repairable as possible but it would be nice to try to get more life out of something that exists. What lightweight distros have you tried?
There potential for smartphones isn’t close to being reached
It’s funny, since I’m involved with legacy jailbreaking, and I really feel like planned obsolescence is the only thing stopping most people from using 10-year-old devices for everything they use them for now.
When I tried both KDE Neon and MX-Linux on my Dell E6400, I found that MX performed better, but KDE Neon wasn’t much behind on that regard. I ultimately decided on KDE Neon because I like vanilla KDE more than MX’s XFCE config.
I guess I have more or less the opposite perspective. I don’t like collecting physical things (harder to store and organize, a pain when moving apartments), although I do have spares for a lot of things that I expect to eventually break
Yeah, I’ve noticed that the similar thoughts I had were leading me down a path of hoarding
That is a completely valid option and something I completely respect, a staggering amount of items can be a hindrance. But now, capitalism unfortunately provides us with devices unfit for being “everything” machines. Thus in a socialist future more reliable and better devices ought to be made, ones that are not held back by planned obsolescence, shitty software and generally the profit motive.
Yeah, I don’t really buy any “new” tech any more because it’s extremely expensive and likely not long-lasting. My phones (thanks to LineageOS) and laptops were all bought used and are about a decade old at this point
Same with me, I love my Thinkpad X61. Beautiful little thing.
I believe as individuals and society we are over reliant on unnecessarily advanced technology and should seek alternatives to distance ourselves from this.
I feel about the same way, to the point I don’t even really want print media to die. We’re still looking at something right in front of us, but at least it isn’t a screen. I’ve been framing it mentally as part of an intentional relationship I want to have with technology, and I think generally others should consider this too. Adopt technology selectively and critically, don’t just let them foist new consumer durables on you, LOL.
I agree with this. I have a lot more trouble with online books compared to having it on paper in front of me. I prefer physical like this in alsmot everything
for any kinda in-depth research, going to my university library and grabbing all the relevant works and having them on hand to quickly switch between is so much better than having several tabs open.
As well as the fact there are so many books that are unavailable digitally and only available as physical books
Yeah, If you try to search for any book on libgen or zlibrary that is not in english, and for example in polish, then good fucking luck! It basically can be considered non existent! I hope that one day I can afford a CZUR book scanner to make this somewhat different as I do have a small collection of Marxist books that were published back in PRL and having scans available would be nice for a lot of people. Because that is the main problem Polish marxists have, lack of availability of materials as no new prints are being made, nothing has been scanned and many books were lost to burnings after 1989…
Prolewiki has some guides to scanning books without those machines if you want to look at them. If you scan them, it would be very intresting to look at as I could translate it into English to read since I’m sure many of those texts are only available in Polish I would think
First order of business is money. I need to get the scanner somehow.
Ah I see. I don’t know if any cheaper options for that to reccomend
My ereader is way easier to focus on than my phone. If you get one make sure it has e Ink because its easier on the eyes.
I try to be as minimalist as possible about the digital software I use and to only use it as a tool, not as endless entertainment. I run a custom dwm, along with CLI only software, my only GUI software is Firefox. I don’t use social media whatsoever, aside from Lemmygrad.
For a while I was on the Gemini protocol, liking the simple aspect of it. Though, it’s become way too reactionary, it’s filled with conservatives debating white genocide and so on. I did find Carl Newport’s Digital Minimalism book of help, though in some aspects it was too bland in my opinion.
Like you said, at the moment we should change how we approach technology itself, and we shouldn’t do it as everything devices. I can hardly focus when I’m not reading on my eBook reader, I don’t even use addictive services. I can use just fine an early 2010s laptop as my main computer, though I can’t come here because the browser lags too much. Everything else is quite good in my case, and it fits my writing needs nicely.
Speaking of analog devices that were replaced by phones, I very much enjoy analog watches. Not the fancy, shiny ones, but normal watches. They’re much more practical than any phone for checking the clock in my opinion. I also own a calculator that’s solar powered, and it’s a great experience.
Yeah I definitely saw what you mean, much of the Linux, Small Web, etc. is very anti-technology and goes reactionary most of the time. Partly cause it’s full of conservatives. I criticise new useless technology such as Smart TVs because it’s capitalism’s way of “innovation” that is predatory, not because new = bad. Too bad there aren’t more leftists in the FOSS communities, though.
Ah, digitally I also tried to be very minimalist by also using only CLI software and running a tiling window manager (sometimes i3 and sometimes dwm). I’ve only recently returned to XFCE as I find it rather simple for a DE and really love it for what it is, something just makes me return to it since we met back in 2016. I really love it, and being relatively hassle free when it comes to configuration has me won over. Sorry, I love the customization a CLI program allows, but I sometimes could use the mouse support or unified theming of GTK that I can easily swap with a singular click.
I also have tried the Gemini and Gopher protocols but haven’t found much worth being posted there… I’m currently planning (key word, planning) on writing a Small Web guide and creating a dedicated Small Web community as I would really like to foster these ideas around people. I also have plans of creating a website that would be available on HTTP, Gopher and Gemini and my target browser is Dillo+. I’ll share more information when I get to it, sooooo yeah. Be sure to be veeeeeery patient…
I’m glad that you are also an analog technology enjoyer, there’s just something else to these devices that smartphones and computers cannot really provide. It’s quite an amazing feeling I like to share with the people I meet, not many people have seen, not even typed, on a typewriter. Sharing the magic is the least I could do.
Yeah I definitely saw what you mean, much of the Linux, Small Web, etc. is very anti-technology and goes reactionary most of the time. Partly cause it’s full of conservatives.
Yeah 4chan’s /g/ is exactly like that, they were the guys that got me to read the Unabomber Manifesto. And even back in my worse days I knew Kaczyński was batshit insane, couldn’t really believe people would unironically try and spread his idiotic message.
I criticise new useless technology such as Smart TVs because it’s capitalism’s way of “innovation” that is predatory, not because new = bad.
And correctly so! My TV is a CRT and it works just fine. And also is a reason why I don’t really care for 4k Ultra HD torrents and just settle for 720p (Remember when 720p was called HD? I sure do). Bruh even standard resolution, known as 480p, is prefect enough for me lmao.
Too bad there aren’t more leftists in the FOSS communities, though.
Look around, they are making your software! Not fanboying about it on reactionary internet forums or shilling shitcoins B)
That at least counts for something and if anything, I can 100% say this with full confidence, and I know she won’t read this but…
Leah Rowe, you were influential in saving me from becoming a disgusting piece of shit. Thank you. It means the world to me.
Xfce is nice! I used it myself for a while, though I came back to tiling, I found it too inefficient. With a twm I can use my computer at the speed I like. I run myself a Gemini capsule and Gopherhole for quite a while now, I could give you more information if you wish!
Speaking of small web communities, check out: https://yesterweb.org. You probably know them, but they recently shut down and put out an amazing manifesto of how to grow a community, you should definitely read it. The admins were also Marxists.
I’m glad that you are also an analog technology enjoyer, there’s just something else to these devices that smartphones and computers cannot really provide. It’s quite an amazing feeling I like to share with the people I meet, not many people have seen, not even typed, on a typewriter. Sharing the magic is the least I could do. I sadly haven’t tried a typewrtier… yet. I’ll see if I can get my hands on one, though the simple editing that you do digitally when writing is unbeatable.
Yeah 4chan’s /g/ is exactly like that, they were the guys that got me to read the Unabomber Manifesto. And even back in my worse days I knew Kaczyński was batshit insane, couldn’t really believe people would unironically try and spread his idiotic message. Look at Luke Smith and how he praises the Unabomber and other such figures, even has a video saying imagination is demonic, lol. Same with DistroTube, both are far-righters.
And correctly so! My TV is a CRT and it works just fine. And also is a reason why I don’t really care for 4k Ultra HD torrents and just settle for 720p (Remember when 720p was called HD? I sure do). Bruh even standard resolution, known as 480p, is prefect enough for me lmao. Yeah there’s a constant competition of “MORE PIXELS! MORE QUALITY!” but it’s barely distinguishable on an average screen. It’s just the techbro conception of “progress”
Look around, they are making your software! Not fanboying about it on reactionary internet forums or shilling shitcoins B) Haha, fair
Edit: Thanks for linking me to Dillo! I’ll check it out. I have experience hosting things, so I could help you, if you want to make something like a community or whatever, if you want.
Now that’s something I haven’t heard of! Thank you for mentioning it, I’ll definitely look into it!
Also you are quoting me wrong, you should add an additional line after the quote to fix it xd
I sadly haven’t tried a typewrtier… yet. I’ll see if I can get my hands on one, though the simple editing that you do digitally when writing is unbeatable.
I think more and pace myself better when typing on a typewriter, I also look out more for mistakes and generally think a lot before I lay it down on paper. It’s a different mode of production you could say, but yes. The versatility of the text editor or word processor is simply unmatched in the modern world. I just like the limitations and requirements that the typewriters put on me.
Look at Luke Smith and how he praises the Unabomber and other such figures, even has a video saying imagination is demonic, lol. Same with DistroTube, both are far-righters.
It’s hard to say the first didn’t influence me, he was one of the few who made Linux videos in 2016 and 2017, before Youtube Linux really blew up. So unfortunately he was the guy I looked up to. Yeaaaahhh… Quite a shameful past, but I’m not afraid to admit it. Luke is the premier petit bougie sympathiser… „Oh you rent? Just buy land soycuck!”. What a fucking moron.
Yeah there’s a constant competition of “MORE PIXELS! MORE QUALITY!” but it’s barely distinguishable on an average screen. It’s just the techbro conception of “progress”
Progress means better treats. That’s unfortunately the mindset of every anti-PRL idiot born in the 1970’s. They didn’t have jeans, Sony, Philips, Nintendo or other shit. Who fucking cares they’ve had guaranteed education, work, housing, high quality healthcare and more. Now that it’s all collapsing it’s just an inconvenience as long as they can keep their white BMW SUV. Fucking hell.
Haha, fair
B)
Also keep in mind, the Dillo+ I linked is a fork of standard Dillo. It add more features including support for Gopher and Gemini. Also thank you for wanting to help me! While UNIX like operating systems is something I pretty much mastered as I’ve got 7 years of experience as a day to day user, hosting is something I’ve yet to get into. I’ll try to figure things out as I go and maybe I’ll nag you when shit hits the fan lmao
Lol this conversation really sums up my linux journey too.
I got curious about electronic typewriters not long ago. My friends got me a straight up old fashioned mechanical one though, lol
Oh electronic typewriters can be very cool and have nice features, they also are still purpose built devices which makes them functionally minimalist in my book. However I still prefer electric typewriters instead, just simpler in construction.
I’m on the same vibe but I’m also a compulsive hoarder, which is why I keep every old tech thing that is still barely functional and try to make them be something useful for what still works. So I have an old phone that serves as a music downloader/player, a notebook I’m turning into a very large e-reader, a couple of busted headphones I use only for sound isolation or testing and the list goes on. I’m still fairly reliant on my phone for browsing, but I’m really not fond of how unified and fragile modern hardware has become.
For the most part “low tech” solutions are not just more efficient in resources, but they’re also much better developed with the dedicated user in mind. Which is why stuff like vim, bash, tmux, arch are usually leagues ahead of their corporate competitors, specially now with the AI craze where not even the developers have control of their product.
Because of autocorrect I forget how to spell. Today I had to look up how committee is spelt. I have turned it off completely everywhere. Spell checkers too.
I have autocorrect off but I still use spell checkers, so whenever I’m typing and I see something is spelled wrong I can treat it like a puzzle and figure out the correct spelling without assistance.
I purposefuly have autocorrect and spell checkers disabled as well, I try my best whe typing on the phone but it sucks because it’s typing on the phone…
While typing on phone I have noticed that I sometimes forget whole words. If I have to go back and edit a sentence there is a 50% chance I end up with some frankenstein garbled mess after. Typing on the phone sucks. Moving the cursor left or right takes up half my cognitive load.
YES, oh my god I have thr exact same problems! I hate to reread my post after posting it and then seeing all the inaccuracies in it.
good god no I couldn’t do this, I’m already extremely disorganized and can’t find my phone wallet or keys for hours in my room at times, can’t imagine how much worse it would be if I had to keep up a bunch of other stuff
Well sinxe your keys, wallet and phone are something that constantly moves and changes position with you, that might be the problem.
Let’s take a few examples, an alarm clock, a radio and a fountain pen.
An alarm clock is something that would have a dedicated place, most likely right next to your bed. Something you rarely, if even, move. Not really a problem I suppose.
A radio is an item of semi movement, you take it places but generally it’s rather big to get easily lost or extremely easily like a pair of keys. At most you might forget to take it. The most modern counterpart to it could be a JBL speaker.
A fountain pen is one most similar to your keys, small, probably moved to many places, and around your home, a lot if you are a student or just prefer pen and paper. Easiest to lose most likely and to forget about.
So as you see, the organization added to manage really depends on the items you have or decide to incorporate into your life. Very much you should take into account how stationery it would be and how, or if, you would lose it.
my point was more that anything extra in my room would make my life even more cluttered and disorganized, it would be a disaster
Understandable
I feel the exact same way, and I’ve been trying to not overly rely on my laptop and smartphone
Techmology. What is that all about? Is it good? Or is it wack?
It’s whack, unless we’re talking about a glove you wear while eating ice cream so the melted ice cream doesn’t get on your hands!
Techmlogy. Neutrl
Techmology + KKKrapitali$m = wack
technolgy + Socialism C: = gud
I try to take a “digital vacation” occasional. I will let my friends/wife know that I’m going to be off-line but hanging out at a bar or a certain part of the city for a few hours with my phone off. I never turn it on for anything, and I just roam around. If I get lost? Good! Maybe i’ll discover something new while I’m roaming and trying to figure out where I am.
Maybe I’ll smoke some weed and just observe stuff, maybe I’ll just lay down in a park for a while, whatever. The point is to disconnect for a while. It’s liberating.
Fucking great man, wandering off and exploring the city is something I ought to do. I could find some nice and niche antique shops this way, and who knows what Marxist literature I’ll find there!
For redundancy I just… have two phones? One has a phone plan, the other is my old phone with a broken screen that I could activate at any time if I somehow lost my main phone. Plus it can act as an internet machine, dupe of my important shit (passwords, locks, contacts), and also its a piece of shit so no one is going to steal it lol
As for low tech solutions, ever checked out Low-Tech Magazine? Good shit
Yeeees, I love Low-Tech Magazine, it’s the good shit. I love their stylistic choice for their pictures. For example I really enjoy their articles of imagining a real existing solar-punk world and not just engaging in idealism. I really liked their article about sailing ships for the 21st century. Also having two phones is not really an answer to these problems for me, not that it feels “wrong”. It’s just that it’s an insufficient answer. I’d rather have many devices that are independent of each other rather than multiple everything devices, I find that preferable.
Great magazine, loved the articles about modern sailing ships and sewage handling by aquaculture.
