It’s a risk to depend on any service that has a risk of becoming unreliable. Both the US and SpaceX (and Musk) have shown services they control will be affected by political pressure.
Most companies are smart enough to obey universal accommodations regulations, or make some of their own, which helps assure continuity of service.
Google, in its Don’t Be Evil days assured users of its services would be defended from state searches and investigations, so it was safe to discuss private matters (or sensitive business correspondence) using Gmail or Google chat. Since then, they’ve discontinued that policy, preferring to favor state interests over private interest, (possibly getting a fat government blab and snitch subsidy) but losing a lot of company clients.
Musk’s reputation precedes him. His vehicles are notoriously dangerous. His ISP service is unreliable. His space program kills technicians at an elevated rate and is shaking apart Texas homes in nearby neighborhoods. And now he’s shown he’ll arbitrarily deny you service during a crisis if he doesn’t like you or your kind.
I’m reminded of Walder Frey in the Song of Ice and Fire that demonstrated he believed he could disregard traditions of accommodations and hospitality to rivals or if someone annoyed him. In the end House Frey had no allies and a lot of enemies.
Actually back in the day Google themselves could be targeted by secret Information Court (FISA) orders for surveillance (including trawling surveilance orders).
I say “secret” because not only such Court orders are not public (in fact most of the proceedings of such Courts are not public), but the targets of those orders cannot admit that they’ve been targeted by them under penalty of emprisionment (i.e. it’s a Crime to let others know about it). Also the way such Courts work is ridiculous and very different from normal Courts (starting by the fact that the proceedings are secret and sometimes the Defense cannot even be present when interrogating certain withnesses), so trying to fight such orders is complicated.
This was PATRIOT act shit. Then on top of that came the Cloud Act shit which meant Google even has to deliver to the US authorities when ordered so data which they are holding in systems in other countries (this kind of thing was admitted to a French Parliamentary inquest by a representative of, not Google, but if I remember it correctly Microsoft).
My point being that your statement that “Google, in its Don’t Be Evil days assured users of its services would be defended from state searches and investigations” is in fact not something we know for sure - they could’ve harped on and on about how they were fighting the visible kind of Court orders all the while secretly obbeying FISA Court orders.
The only company we know for sure were serious about “don’t be evil” in the US was an provider of encrypted e-mail, were the owner of the company actually closed down the company and took down its servers rather than obbey such orders.
If an American company holding private user and/or corporate data large enough for at least some of it to be interesting to the US Authorities or well-connected American is still running, they’re almost surelly silently obbeying one or more of such orders.
Always, ALWAYS, ALWAYS assume that any information you have which has political importance, can be used to blackmail your or anybody else, can be use to derive social connection information or would be beneficiary for well-connected companies (especially US ones) to know about (i.e. stuff of interest for industrial espionage) when in the hands of an American company, even if held in servers outside the US and no matter how loudly those companies claim to be trying to protect your privacy (in fact, it’s a good rule of thumb that “the louder they deny, the most likely they’re doing it”) can and will be given not just to the US Authorities but, given how profoundly corrupt the US is, also to rich and well connected American individuals and corporations if it’s of interest for them.
It’s a risk to depend on any service that has a risk of becoming unreliable. Both the US and SpaceX (and Musk) have shown services they control will be affected by political pressure.
Most companies are smart enough to obey universal accommodations regulations, or make some of their own, which helps assure continuity of service.
Google, in its Don’t Be Evil days assured users of its services would be defended from state searches and investigations, so it was safe to discuss private matters (or sensitive business correspondence) using Gmail or Google chat. Since then, they’ve discontinued that policy, preferring to favor state interests over private interest, (possibly getting a fat government blab and snitch subsidy) but losing a lot of company clients.
Musk’s reputation precedes him. His vehicles are notoriously dangerous. His ISP service is unreliable. His space program kills technicians at an elevated rate and is shaking apart Texas homes in nearby neighborhoods. And now he’s shown he’ll arbitrarily deny you service during a crisis if he doesn’t like you or your kind.
I’m reminded of Walder Frey in the Song of Ice and Fire that demonstrated he believed he could disregard traditions of accommodations and hospitality to rivals or if someone annoyed him. In the end House Frey had no allies and a lot of enemies.
Actually back in the day Google themselves could be targeted by secret Information Court (FISA) orders for surveillance (including trawling surveilance orders).
I say “secret” because not only such Court orders are not public (in fact most of the proceedings of such Courts are not public), but the targets of those orders cannot admit that they’ve been targeted by them under penalty of emprisionment (i.e. it’s a Crime to let others know about it). Also the way such Courts work is ridiculous and very different from normal Courts (starting by the fact that the proceedings are secret and sometimes the Defense cannot even be present when interrogating certain withnesses), so trying to fight such orders is complicated.
This was PATRIOT act shit. Then on top of that came the Cloud Act shit which meant Google even has to deliver to the US authorities when ordered so data which they are holding in systems in other countries (this kind of thing was admitted to a French Parliamentary inquest by a representative of, not Google, but if I remember it correctly Microsoft).
My point being that your statement that “Google, in its Don’t Be Evil days assured users of its services would be defended from state searches and investigations” is in fact not something we know for sure - they could’ve harped on and on about how they were fighting the visible kind of Court orders all the while secretly obbeying FISA Court orders.
The only company we know for sure were serious about “don’t be evil” in the US was an provider of encrypted e-mail, were the owner of the company actually closed down the company and took down its servers rather than obbey such orders.
If an American company holding private user and/or corporate data large enough for at least some of it to be interesting to the US Authorities or well-connected American is still running, they’re almost surelly silently obbeying one or more of such orders.
Always, ALWAYS, ALWAYS assume that any information you have which has political importance, can be used to blackmail your or anybody else, can be use to derive social connection information or would be beneficiary for well-connected companies (especially US ones) to know about (i.e. stuff of interest for industrial espionage) when in the hands of an American company, even if held in servers outside the US and no matter how loudly those companies claim to be trying to protect your privacy (in fact, it’s a good rule of thumb that “the louder they deny, the most likely they’re doing it”) can and will be given not just to the US Authorities but, given how profoundly corrupt the US is, also to rich and well connected American individuals and corporations if it’s of interest for them.