The day after the Democrats trounced the Republicans in the midterm elections, Ezra Klein of the New York Times tweeted, “One of the more exciting parts of this election — among many — is the return of a religious left.” Accompanying the enthusiastic remark was a clip from his interview earlier this year with James Talarico, the Democrat who won the Texas senatorial race. In the clip, Talarico — a Presbyterian seminarian — advocates a political attitude in which Americans recognize each other as being made in God’s image and treat each other accordingly. He calls this “an incarnational politics.”

Incarnational politics — hoo boy. The term, a nearly paradoxical union of the sacred and the profane, sounds just enough like intersectional politics to catch the attention of progressives. It also sounds like an edgy indie band that never quite made it. (“I saw Incarnational Politics open for Bad Religion in ’91.”)

Talarico explains that incarnational politics starts from the premise that “even if you’re not formally religious, if you do believe that each person is sacred, that each person is holy, that each person bears the divine image, that should fundamentally change how we engage in politics, how we treat our neighbors, and how we treat our enemies.”

The mundane truth is that you do not receive divine grace by voting. You do get a sticker, though.

Through this “incarnational politics,” Talarico believes he “can love my neighbor at scale: through good public policy, reducing the cost of prescription drugs, reducing the cost of childcare, the cost of housing.” Incarnational politics happen to align with progressive policy priorities.

It’s fun to imagine how aspiring seminarians-cum-senators could use other theological concepts this way. “A truly trinitarian politics would recognize that there are more than two genders!” “A transubstantiationary politics would help us understand how important bread and wine are, and make sure everyone has plenty of both!”

One problem with Talarico’s theory is that he conflates the Incarnation (“The Word was made Flesh, and dwelt among us”) and the Imago Dei (“And God said, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness”). These are related but distinct concepts. But fine, let’s play along and agree that they both gesture toward the idea that we should treat our neighbors like ourselves and love our enemies. When President Trump told Ross Douthat that he doesn’t think he can bring himself to forgive his political enemies, he showed how difficult it can be to treat our political adversaries with Christian charity.

  • irgendjemand@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    ·
    2 hours ago

    And if I don’t believe people are holy and sacred? Can’t we just treat each other with respect for no ulterior motive?

    • I_Jedi@lemmy.today
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      2 minutes ago

      Ah, but the LORD says that undue respect is a sign of weakness, and thus evil. For you see, helping others while getting nothing in return is actually a sign of demonic influence. God always exacts a price.

  • Zaktor@sopuli.xyz
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    11
    ·
    3 hours ago

    LOL. The National Review having an opinion on a religious Democratic politician.

    Incarnational politics happen to align with progressive policy priorities.

    Yes, it’s almost like people who really believe in all that crazy talk by Jesus about caring for the poor would end up with aligned with progressive politics.

    National Review sure wants to convince people that religiosity is just a personal styling fully compatible with cutting food programs and bombing brown people for their oil.