• SinAdjetivos@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    3 days ago

    look at the actual data

    Would you like to provide the data you’re referencing? Because what data I’m aware of is nowhere near as black and white as you suggest.

    that doesn’t mean that drug testing pregnant mothers is a bad policy inherently ___ it’s a good policy, with sub-par implementation

    What is the goal with the drug tests? If it’s to determine what additional resources and medical care will be needed then I agree with you. If the goal is incarceration and punishment, which is the majority of “resources” CPS has to offer, then it’s actively harmful.

    Good policy fundamentally requires good implementation. Don’t forget when forced sterilization was just “good policy” for the exact reasons you’re outlining above. The “sub-par implementation” you’re describing has the same ultimate result, just with a lot more orphans.