• 0 Posts
  • 40 Comments
Joined 3 months ago
cake
Cake day: January 26th, 2026

help-circle


  • How do you define cruelty without God being real?

    Pretty simply, do you require help knowing the difference between what is cruel and what is not? You might need psychiatric help my guy

    How can you know for sure that God is apathetic or ignorant?

    Because of the suffering of innocents. Any all powerful creature that allows suffering on the scale we are familiar with either doesn’t know about it, and is thus ignorant, or doesn’t care, and is thus apathetic. Perhaps this creature both knows and cares, in which case it is either powerless to stop it, and therefore not all powerful, or it is a cruel being, and not one by which to set your moral compass.

    If there is no basis for objective morality at all,

    There isn’t. Morality is a supposition.

    we have no grounds to condemn other cultures for actions that go against our culture.

    This relies on a number of assumptions which are mostly wrong. Am I condemning an entire culture or the actions of a few people? Do the people of that culture think this is a good idea? Are there members of that group that condemn this? Are those members represented? Is the practice being condemned harmful?

    I would condemn cruelty happening abroad because I believe everyone is made in the image of God, and God’s commandment for all of Humanity was to love one and other. If God isn’t real, then why should I care what happens in other countries, if the only morality I have is based on my white, western culture?

    So you require someone else to tell you what is right and what is not? Are you incapable of independent thought? Are you devoid of compassion and empathy?

    An empathetic person would abhor the suffering of others without divine intervention.

    Should God appear to you and demand you sacrifice your eldest son, would you begin sharpening your knife?

    If there is no God, humans are just lumps of cells anyway, not too far removed from plants and animals.

    We are not removed greatly from animals no. We are animals. We’re pretty far removed from plants though.

    So why would it be my business what is going on abroad

    Empathy my guy. I was kind of kidding before but now I’m actually concerned you lack basic emotional skills that are natural and innate to most people. That’s definitionally psychopathy, you might want to look in to that.

















  • Objective morality isn’t real. If it were, you’d be able to prove it.

    And it’s difficult to argue, coming from a deeply red area of the US that I’m coming from a culture that vilifies the death penalty.

    The closest you’ll ever get to an objective moral truth is that you’re free to believe any fucking thing you want, but your rights stop at you. Imposing your beliefs on another living being is supremacy.