It’s not about the IDEA of communism its the implementation

Let’s see what this person’s sources for how socialist implementation looked like:

Read the gulhag archipeligo

Lmfao, a fucking fiction book written by a fringe fascist-tsarist right wing nationalist. Your comment can be safely disregarded once we learn that your source on “socialist implementation” is literally a work of fiction. “Communism doesn’t work in practice, you should watch The Avengers: Age of Ultron”-ass comment

You should try and read a normal book for adults, you know, an actual essay discussing the facts from a scientific standpoint and not a propaganda novel.

Go and read a real book for adults. I suggest you Albert Szymanski’s “Human Rights in the Soviet Union” or “Is the Red Flag Flying”, or Robert C. Allen’s “Farm to Factory” if you’re as concerned with the realities of Soviet people as you’re showing us.

The Soviet Union were literally the closest allies of the Nazis

No, fuck you actually. I’m a Spaniard, and back in 1936 before any “Motherboard-Ribbedcock” anticommunist propaganda you’re making (I’ve educated you about this topic before and you just refuse to absorb the facts), the Soviets were the ONLY country in the world arming the antifascists in Spain against Franco and Hitler. You’re the saddest excuse for a propagandist I’ve seen, literally carrying water for genocidal maniacs and landlords while our societies collapse due to climate change and fascist takeover of our institutions. I refuse to entertain your bullshit, asshole.

communism is notorious for dragging societies into poverty

Socialist Romania had a growth of 800% of GDP per capita averaging at over 4% growth per year. Capitalist Romania averages out at about 2.5% GDP growth per year. A similar thing happened in Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, Moldova, Bulgaria… Most Eastern Block countries saw massive destruction of living standards and economic progress during the transition to capitalism, you’d know this if you listened ONE time, you disgusting bullshitter.

You’re literally a fucking genocidal maniac supporting the destruction of Eastern Europe in the name of Capitalism.

Yeah yeah, European chauvinism yadda yadda

“You don’t know? Chinese people liking their government means they’re a dictatorship for some reason, seeseepee!!!111!1!11!1! All factual data about China can be disregarded because I’m a racist prick who doesn’t conceive the idea that Chinese are free to speak their minds!!!”

Shut up, boring-ass pro-landlord propagandist

I’m talking to this gorilla user, they’re everywhere whenever communism is mentioned carrying water for capitalism and its horrors

You’re such a boring anticommunist proapgandist, you’ve been educated a million times in this platform and you refuse to absorb the smallest knowledge.

If communism doesnt work, why did it take 1bn people out of poverty and save Europe from Nazism?

You cannot have real democracy when there is a ruling minority class, as in capitalism, simple as that.

You have far fewer desperate people to feed into the meat grinder

Funnily enough, socialist countries typically don’t feature unemployment, making the utilization of labor more effective. Also, planned economy has immense potential in the information era.

you have to be right everywhere every time or the oppressors will magnify your failures both at home and abroad

You have tools to curb this, there’s a reason why the great internet firewall exists.

your researchers aren’t researching almost exclusively weapons of mass destruction

Fair enough lmao

No. You’re wrong.

I’m from Spain, we had fascism for 40 years. We had no public education for everyone, no free healthcare for everyone, no guaranteed employment, no right to unionize, no pensions, no guaranteed housing, university was only for the rich families, farm workers were exploited by the landowners, there was immense racism and ethnonationalism as state policy, and other cultures and languages (see Basque and Catalan) were forbidden and repressed.

Communism is literally antithetical to fascism, it provides universal free healthcare, universal pensions, guaranteed right to employment, guaranteed housing at affordable prices, universal free education to the highest level, respect for local cultures and languages, socialist internationalism as opposed to ethnonationalism, highest unionization rates, redistribution of the farmlands… This is the reason why the first thing fascists do is murdering all communists, anarchists and socialists

I suggest you read more on what fascism actually was, and what communism has historically actually been.

I wanna call it “dope-ass fucking actually existing communism”

-Marxism-Leninism

looks inside

-Engelsism-Leninism

doesn’t allow their people to not like them

According to western surveys too? So, everything good about China is fake news, nice maga hat you’re wearing there! “Democracy perceptions is also Gynese propaganda!!!”

Not very relevant distinction for the murdered children

Communists don’t advocate for genocidal or imperialist states, though, you may be confusing reality with CIA propaganda

Yes, Argentina suffered a CIA sponsored fascist regime that consolidated the wealth, media and power of the country in a select far right elite, and they’re still suffering the consequences, this is part of the same problem

exactly why hexbears don’t have comrades

I have plenty of online and IRL comrades, not sure what you mean.

Simping for dictators

I’ve never simped for dictators, you just mistake “foreign nation with geopolitical interests opposite from the US” with dictators.

My dear democracy-lover, what’s your opinion on the recent push for grassroots democracy in socialist Vietnam? They’re eliminating an entire echelon of bureaucrats quickly and giving the budgets and decision-making power directly to local councils to administer directly. Surely since you’re a democracy lover you’re aware of this and you support it?

Third such fundraiser too! Here’s to many more, maybe the trend goes to other instances?

Thanks for the candid words. It seems that people get more bothered over theoretical ideological points than the results of the theory. I’ll be very happy if .world users decide to own hexbear epic style and do a 10 times larger fundraiser for Palestine

The state already chooses what people can read or say. I live in the EU, all Russian media are banned here. I fundamentally don’t disagree with banning Russian media, but it proves that this already happens, it’s just that the state sees that generally western media dominate internationally and it allows us to read it.

In the context of China, if the alternatives are between banning western media and not banning it, the success of the Chinese model and its resilience against western intelligence and propaganda make it obvious to me that the firewall was the correct choice in retrospect, however unsavory it may seem from the outside.

Since you’re so excited about being exposed to all media: do you personally go out of your way to watch Russian, Chinese, Cuban or Iranian media and engage with their citizens online, or does your “media freedom” de-facto result in you exclusively consuming western sources?

The alternative is “free speech” dominated by western tech oligarchs in platforms subjected to intelligence monitoring and constant western interference. It’s exactly these things leading to murderers like Bolsonaro and Milei being elected.

Awful stuff they do, or things they say you don’t like? Two very different things.